A Predictable Plot Saved By Its Star Charm

What do you get when you combine an Italian vineyard, a Disney princess, and a Bridgerton Duke? A story that’s a little too “old school”, with enough charm that you can’t help but forgive it. Live action The Little Mermaid actress Halle Bailey and Bridgerton season 1 star Regé-Jean Page gathered You, Me & Tuscanya kind of enemies-to-lovers, kind of love triangle romantic comedy set against a beautiful Tuscan backdrop.

When American floater and houseguest Anna (Bailey) has a nearly one-night stand with Italian realtor Matteo (Lorenzo de Moor), she decides it’s time to take the leap and travel to Italy, where she stays in Matteo’s empty villa. However, after being discovered by her mother, Anna had to think quickly and claimed to be Matteo’s fiancee. The problem is, the family is completely in love with her – including Matteo’s muscular and often bedraggled brother, Michael (Page).

You, Me & Tuscany Have One Condition: Suspend Your Disbelief, And You’ll Have Fun

Perhaps the biggest surprise You, Me & Tuscany is how little the trailer has left to reveal. In it, Anna’s best friend, Claire (Aziza Scott), directly asks Anna, “You pretend to be a white Italian man’s fiancée but end up falling for a black Italian cousin?” This is basically the entire plot, without any other significant surprises, until the end.

If You, Me & Tuscany However, there is one real drawback, namely not knowing which demographic to target. The film, which is rated PG-13, uses permitted F-bombs from the start, and while that doesn’t automatically orient the film toward older teens and above, the phallic cucumber jokes –and pretty much anything that comes out of Francesca’s (Stella Pecollo) mouth – certainly do.

However, most of the tunes are not suitable for teens and older adults. The film asks many of its viewers questions about suspended disbelief, and while it sometimes handles its cheesier moments by poking fun at itself, there are times when the cringe-worthy lines are delivered with absolute sincerity. In fact, especially in the early stages, You, Me & Tuscany seems destined to be another trope-y romantic comedy that fails to differentiate itself.

What ultimately saves this film is undoubtedly the cast. Unsurprisingly, considering their respective romantic backgrounds, Bailey and Page are everything audiences could want in a romantic comedy lead. Both of them are funny, charming, and absolutely stunning, something that is You, Me & Tuscany exploitation at every turn (seriously, they’re drenched from head to toe at several points in the film).

The relatively small supporting cast also has some unexpected twists. Although she somewhat questions her target demo, Pecollo’s Fracesca is the single funniest character in the entire film, and her dialogue is often so unexpected and surprising that it’s no surprise to find that she ad-libs most of it. If Pecollo hasn’t tried stand-up comedy yet, that should be the next step in his career.

Marco Calvani’s Lorenzo, a taxi driver who becomes a mentor to Anna, is another scene stealer. Calvani has surprisingly few entries in his filmography, but his is one of the brightest spots You, Me & Tuscany. (Think Jared Leto Gucci Houseif the accent is authentic and all the jokes are heard.)

Capturing the fierce love of the unique Italian nonna brand is no easy feat, but Stefania Casini’s Nonna Alessia is nearly perfect. Stoic and observing for most of the film, he breaks his silence towards the end You, Me & Tuscany and confirms that he is actually one of the best characters in the entire story.

However, not all characters are given interesting storylines. In fact, in contrast to the more common issue where films treat women as plot devices rather than fully formed characters, Matteo has little screen time and even less personality. Her role primarily centers on her oddball status within her family and the problems she creates for Michael and Anna’s much better love story.

Although she is charming at first and is basically the driving force behind Anna’s storyline, when she finally returns to Italy and reconnects with her family, she becomes a bit of a whiny, self-centered person. In the end, it was not resolved. He throws his car keys to Anna at a key moment, which earns him some points, but then the story ends in a truly confusing way that is perhaps the only narrative disappointment in the entire film.

Claire, played by Scott, is also positioned as the main character in most of the advertisements You, Me & Tuscanywhich made it a bit disappointing because, after the first 20 minutes or so, he was basically absent. He continues to exchange text messages and voice messages with Anna, but their time together on screen is very limited. This is a shame, not only because the two have great chemistry, but also because Claire is the only black woman who actually interacts with Anna, and seeing their friendship on screen means a lot.

However, aside from some unsatisfying character choices, You, Me & Tuscany delivers the lighthearted fun and beautiful backdrops it promises. Is it realistic that an American woman with a fairly good grasp of Italian could travel to Italy, become a squatter, and end up with a beautiful new boyfriend and a loving family? No, but audiences rarely watch romantic comedies looking for realism. Instead, they got an Italian fairy tale, peppered with genuinely funny moments, a brilliant cast and some unexpected twists Bridgerton/A Shonda Rhimes reference that reflects the film’s lightheartedness and willingness to poke fun at itself.

You, Me & Tuscany is widely released in theaters on Friday, April 10.

Release Date

April 10, 2026

Processing time

104 Minutes

Director

Kat Coiro

Writer

Ryan Engle, Kristin Engle

Producer

Johanna Byer, Will Packer

Cast

• 

•